Michelle: "I woke up with a black eye." Ashley Spivey: "Where did Michelle's black eye come from?"
Good question. A source on the set of The Bachelor told HollywoodLife.com that "no one" knows where Michelle got that black eye, but there's speculation that it may have been self-inflicted in an attempt to get Brad Womack's attention. (That sounds pretty far-fetched, but she is an actress.) "She just somehow gets a black eye," the source said. "She woke up and bam, black eye."
Reality Steve added, "Apparently it's just a big mystery as to what happened."
Did she get into a fight? Stumble drunk into bed and hit her head? Paint it on with makeup? What gives? In the meantime, check out this trailer for the upcoming movie Midway to Heaven, featuring Michelle in the role of a hot jogger: