Why he might be “A”:Noel Kahn (Brant Daugherty) was the DJ at the Rosewood fashion extravaganza, which means he had exclusive access to the disc of images for the catwalk. He would have had plenty of time to switch Spencer (Troian Bellisario)’s pictures of Alison (Sasha Pieterse) for something far more sinister, and the way he snuck on up Aria (Lucy Hale) as she fervently gathered up her collection of Tresemme products was downright creepy.
Why he might not be “A”: We’ve suspected Noel in the past, and each time we’ve been positive that he’s “A,” something happens to clear his name. We want to think he’s “A,” but he might just be a run-of-the-mill, first class weirdo.
Why she might be “A”: Jessica organized the fashion show, which means she knew the ins and outs of the program, and could have easily arranged those candles in the shape of an “A” while no one was looking. It was also her idea to pay tribute to Alison... Did she plan her daughter’s memorial just so she could ruin it?
Why she might not be “A”: As far as we know, Jessica’s been absent from Rosewood since Alison’s death, which would make it difficult to stalk four teenager girls. Then again, people in Rosewood seem surprisingly comfortable with living under strange conditions, so you never know!
Why he might be “A”: What was Jason DiLaurentis (Drew Van Acker) doing listening in on Aria and Noel’s conversation? Shouldn’t he have been comforting his mom, or building a fence somewhere? If you ask us, Jason was a bit too quick to break that disc of Ali’s unhappy ending in half — so what was he trying to hide?
Why he might not be “A”: Maybe Jason’s just a really good, really pretty little liar, but he seems genuinely distraught over his sister’s death. Plus, we refuse to believe that someone so studly would be a murderer. It just can’t happen!
Why he might be “A”: Spencer’s dad was acting majorly suspicious during his phone convos with Jessica DiLaurentis. Why are they in communication, and why is Mr. Hastings so riled up? We’re thinking one of two things: 1) Mr. Hastings and Jessica are in cahoots, or 2) Jason is their secret love child.
Why he might not be “A”: Mr. Hastings is one more binge-eating session away from putting himself into a diabetic coma. “A” would never risk his/her life of crime for a few sugary sweets! Also, Mr. Hastings seems very concerned about Spencer, and as we all know, “A” really doesn’t care if the little liars live or die.