That doesn’t leave many options. Katherine (Nina Dobrev) seems like a logical choice, but she’s supposedly half way to Antarctica by now. Maybe Caroline (Candice Accola) and Damon rekindle their Season 1 passion? What about Rebekah (Claire Holt)? Damon didn’t seem to mind getting flirty with her in the woods before she stuck him in the gut with a marshmallow-roasting stick.