On Watch What Happens! Live’s after-show, when Andy questioned Snooki on the elusive question of whether or not she hooked up with The Situation early on in her relationship with Jionni LaValle, in front of The Unit, Snooks said “hell frickin’ no.” And JWOWW, standing up for her future spin-off co-star and BFF, made a pretty convincing case for her.
In this clip, watch JWOWW’s logical thought process on display: if Snooki immediately confessed to Jionni that she had smushed Vinny eight months into their relationship, and he forgave her, why would Snooki lie about hooking up with Mike when they were only two weeks into the relationship?
Sadly, Snooki remembers that she and Mike “were legit best friends” before this rumor even started.
Also in this clip: Snooki gives a fellow meatball caller diet tips!
Catch an all-new Jersey Shore on Thursday, February 9 at 10pm ET/PT on MTV.