Much to our dismay, David beat out Nathan (read: kicked Nathan's ass) by a pretty large percentage, an outcome we've attributed to that grainy, low-res completely unsexy image of Nathan. Seriously, guys, how is that even fair?!
Instead of wallowing in self-pity, we've decided to run our own Nathan vs. David poll to determine which former Buffy star looks best in a good old-fashioned suit and tie.
You tell us, Castle fans. Which hunk would you rather walk the red carpet with: Nathan Fillion or David Boreanaz?