So what happened to her? Shay Mitchell has promised we will see Maya again, so it sounds like she's still alive, but alive doesn't have to mean well. These are our top four theories about her fate:
She was kidnapped by "A": At the end of the episode, "A" bought a newspaper with a featured story about Maya's disappearance. Could "A" be gloating? Maybe the reason Emily only got one call from Maya was that "A" took her phone, and she only managed to get it back for a moment.
She was kidnapped by someone else: "A" isn't the only evil person in Rosewood, and it's possible "A" was just as baffled by Maya's MIA status as the rest of us.
She's actually working with "A": Maybe the person in the car was "A," but wasn't a stranger to Maya. Perhaps she and her potential partner in crime are working closely together again, and "A" was picking up the newspaper to see what the rest of the world knows about her fate.
She is "A": It's like the theory above, but flipped: The person in the car is the helper, and Maya herself is "A." Hey, it's possible!
Of course, she could have just hitched a ride with some well-meaning person heading across country, but on this show, we're pretty sure the answer is never that simple.
What do you think? Vote in our poll, and weigh in at our Facebook page.