To further explore this theory, we've put these telling pictures of the Black Swan next to a photo of Melissa. We can't be the only ones who see the similarity, right?
Of course, Melissa isn't the only one the Black Swan looks like. A lot of fans argue that the Swan looks like Ashley Marin (Laura Leighton), and others have speculated that it could be Dr. Sullivan or even Jackie, Ezra's (Ian Harding) vindictive ex. Those are definitely possibilities too, though we don't think any else tops Melissa's combo of plausible looks and obvious motivation.