The 13th spot will go to one of these three stars: Carson Kressley from Season 14, Sabrina Bryan from Season 5, or Kyle Massey from Season 11.
All three proved to be highly entertaining, so it may come down to their respective talents. While everyone loves Carson, Kyle was one of the most-improved dancers in DWTS history, and we all remember how heartbreaking it was when Sabrina was prematurely booted. Tell us who you’ll be voting for in the poll below!
Dancing With the Stars Season 15: All-Stars will premiere on Monday, September 24 at 8 p.m. ET/PT onABC.