The X Factor

The X Factor’s Dinah Jane vs. The Glee Project’s Nellie: Who Sang It Better — Beyonce’s “If I Were a Boy”

Dinah Jane Hansen blew us away with her rendition of Beyonce’s “If I Were A Boy” in her X Factor audition last night. Her singing even made judge L.A. Reid remark “you took that song to places even Beyonce didn’t.” (Woah — watch your back Bey.)

While we were watching this amazingness unfold, it brought us back to an episode of another favorite show of ours, The Glee Project and the beautiful version of the same song contestant Nellie Veitenheimer (who was SUPER UNJUSTLY CUT, not that we’re still bitter) performed.

While both versions are show-stoppingly magical, we wanted to put it to a vote. Which singer gave the song new life in the most can’t-turn-your-head-away fashion?

Want more X Factor goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!

09.27.2012 / 10:58 PM EDT by Julia Wayne
Related: The X Factor, Glee

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on Twitter