Read spoilers at your own risk! For more on Wetpaint Entertainment's philosophy on spoilers, click here.
As we’ve pointed out, Toby will probably survive the Halloween episode, since we know someone finds out that he’s on the “A” team in Season 3, Episode 16: "Misery Loves Company." And judging from this preview, it looks like he’s feeling mighty good about himself as he strolls into the party with a gorgeous (and clueless) Spencer (Troian Bellisario) on his arm.
While we’ve been focused on who will die in the episode, we haven’t spent much time thinking about who will kill that person. Yes, it’s certainly possible that someone dies a natural death — they could fall off the moving train (which is totally a safety hazard!) or someone could die in an accident having nothing to do with the Halloween party at all. But considering the possible victims are all major PLL characters, we’re going to assume that there will be foul play.
That said, who in Rosewood is really capable of murder? Someone killed Alison (Sasha Pieterse), and her dead body and autopsy report proved it. We’ve always assumed that “A” killed her, but now there are several “A”s, making up the “A” team. All we know so far is that Mona (Janel Parrish) and Toby are on the team, and now that the shock of finding out about Toby is wearing off, we’re no longer looking at him as a damaged soul. We’re thinking that he might just be evil.
Could Toby kill? We know he has been to therapy in the past (that’s how Alison found out about him and Jenna (Tammin Sursok), by digging through his files), and there’s also his strange connection to Dr. Sullivan (who some believe is his mother). There is also the fact that “A” has sent things like human teeth to the Liars, suggesting a pathological mind at work. With no parents around, or any supervision or accountability, we think it’s definitely possible that Toby could be a murderer.
Do you think Toby will be the one who kills in the Halloween episode? Share your thoughts below!