They came across Alison, who at that point was still missing. Alison immediately starts taunting Jenna, who was blind at the time. “You have a really bad memory,” she tells her. “I told you what would happen if you came back.”
Jenna reacts by blindly (sorry) swinging at Alison, even grabbing a field hockey stick and threatening Alison with it. Garrett takes the stick from her hands and swings at Ali, who crouches and misses being hit. But she and Garrett complicitly decide to make Jenna think Garrett “took care of it.”
Then Garrett went back to the yard without Jenna later that night, and he saw Alison having a strange conversation with Byron Montgomery (Chad Lowe)! Alison tells him, “You never paid for your mistakes.” Byron says, “You say all these grown-up things but you’re still a child.” Alison replies, “You know what I’m capable of.”
How did Alison and Byron know so much about each other? Share your reactions in the comments!