We explored this question before the Halloween special, but after seeing it, we have more clues. Here is what we learned about the joker from the episode.
Long red nails. Whoever was wearing the costume was also wearing long, red glue-on nails. Does this necessarily mean that the joker is a girl? After all, when Spencer (Troian Bellisario) showed one of the broken nails to Hanna (Ashley Benson) after the attack, Hanna said, “That’s a big girl...” And Spencer says, “Maybe it’s not for a girl at all.”
The joker poisoned Aria. Clearly, the joker is part of the group of people who tried to kill Aria (Lucy Hale), since he or she is the one that carried poison inside their ring, waiting for a moment when Aria wasn’t looking, and dropping it in her drink.
Wren, Ezra, and Byron are all on our list for the episode’s “Who Is ‘A’?” roundup, so do you think any of them were wearing double costumes? Wren, after all, would have access to that kind of poison. And we don’t know where Jason was for most of the episode.
Tell us who you think the joker was in the comments below!