Now, Garrett, another member of the NAT club, is dead. Garrett would have seen the same footage, since he was part of the club that shot it. With two members dead, is Jason next?
We have one theory, especially considering Alison’s murder. Since we know Toby (Keegan Allen) is “A,” what if he is trying to kill off everyone who saw footage of him and step-sister Jenna (Tammin Sursok) involved in a compromising position?
As we know, Alison found out that Toby and Jenna had a sexual relationship. She’s dead. Those who may have seen actual footage of the relationship are slowly being killed. One reason why Jason may be spared, for the moment, is that he was so often high or drunk, that he might not even remember what he saw.
Toby would then have to presume that, since Alison knew about him and Jenna, then the Liars would too. Hence, his torture and fear tactics with the Liars.
Another theory could be that whatever the NAT club saw and filmed is something we don’t yet know about. But whatever it was, the “A” team could be determined to keep it a secret. What if, perhaps, the NAT club shot footage of Alison’s secret twin? If she were determined to remain hidden, she might want to make sure they all kept their mouths shut. Permanently.
The next question is, what will happen to Jason, Melissa (Torrey DeVitto) (who was also in Ali’s bedroom), and Jenna? Share your thoughts in the comments below!