Though, as we’ve already seen, it’s undeniable that the Original has gotten under the blond vamp’s skin. (He’s also gotten some under-the-shirt action when he pretended to be Tyler!) And while certain members of the supernatural community might consider Klaus the epitome of evil, the hybrid-maker has a soft spot when it comes to the reigning Miss Mystic Falls. Plus, we know this guy doesn’t give up without a fight — especially now that Tyler’s possible affair with the newest werewolf in town, Hayley (Phoebe Tonkin), is out of the bag.
So, in a world where Caroline discovers Tyler’s secret tryst and needs a shoulder to cry on, would it be Klaus’s? Will the cheerleader-turned-bloodsucker ever be able to forgive Klaus? Our Klaroline fantasies hope the answer is, “Yes!”