But, seriously. Tyler was pretty cagey when Klaus questioned him about his time alone in the mountains with Hayley (Phoebe Tonkin). Who knows what happened when his animal instincts took over while he was breaking his sire bond. Sidenote: Does it count as cheating if you’re transformed into another animal at the time? Asking for a friend.
Well, things don’t look rosy for Forwood at the moment. Klaus is rumored to be Caroline’s date to the Miss Mystic Falls pageant in Season 4, Episode 7, “My Brother’s People,” and some new photos from that episode show she’s at least willing to speak to the Original.
But, hey. We’re not entirely convinced Tyler cheated on Caroline. Those two have been through a lot together — we just wish he’d told his vampy girlfriend about Hayley sooner.