5. He has never won a Mirror Ball. Shocking, we know. Because of a string of less than top-notch star partners, Tony hasn't even made the finals since he danced with Melissa Rycroft in Season 8. He told us that dancing with Melissa during the All-Stars season was a chance to "press a refresh button" on his DWTS career.
Dancing With the Stars airs Mondays and Tuesdays onABC.