However, that theory got blown out of the water on Season 3, Episode 22: "Will the Circle Be Unbroken?" when Wilden showed up alive and well, claiming that he'd been on a "fishing vacation."
This raises several questions. First, what was Wilden really up to? Because we have a feeling he didn't just nip off for a quick vacay after being hit by Ashley Marin (Laura Leighton). Second: If he's not dead, who was in the woods?
At this point, we're worried that it either really was Toby, or that it was Jason. We don't want Toby or Jason to be dead, and we prefer to believe that, whatever his motivations for being on the "A" team, Toby wouldn't be cruel enough to completely destroy Spencer.
What do you make of this development? Share your thoughts in the comments below!