Keegan (aka Toby Cavanaugh) posted his first, starting off the video with a ridiculous duck face and then exclaiming, “Happy birthday, Shannon — I love you!” Of course, he had to follow it with a song, singing, “Happy birthday, Shay Mitchell!” before plugging his event this Saturday in Virginia. However, he brought it all back to his girl after — but you’ll have to watch the video below to see what sweet note he ended on.
The Keek love fest didn’t stop there, though. Ashley (aka Hanna Marin) made up an original birthday song, singing, “Whose birthday is it today? Who is it? Oh, it’s my Shannon!” before grabbing Shay for a true serenade. “Don’t even tell me ‘cause she’s so special to me,” she continued while laughing and trying to keep Shay from shoving the camera away. Clearly her co-star was embarrassed, but it was the most adorable thing ever and we’re glad she kept going!