Watch Amber Holcomb Sing Pink’s “Just Give Me a Reason” on American Idol 2013 Top 4 5/1/2013
For her first song on American Idol 2013 Top 4, Amber Holcomb chose Pink's "Just Give Me a Reason." She admitted to not knowing the song very well, and it showed in her performance.
Nicki Minaj thinks Amber was just disconnected from the song and this isn’t the Amber they know and love. Her voice is still amazing though.
Randy Jackson says it just was not stellar for him tonight and it needs to be stellar at this point in the competition. He wants to know if she had fun. Amber says she had to think about the lyrics (which was obvious because it seemed like she struggled).
Mariah Carey says she wants everyone to understand how difficult it is to learn a current song like this, but it is hard for all the girls.
Keith Urban says P!nk is a phenomenal singer and people underestimate how difficult her songs really are in their range and tempo. It takes years of getting comfortable with yourself to really have total confidence on stage. He loves the clarity of her voice though.