“Alison stands at a window which is lined with shelves,” reads the scene set during the day in Toby’s bedroom. “We’ve been here before and the shelves were filled with snow-globes. Now they’re lined with model cars and motorcycles.
“‘So these are your toys?’ asks Alison. Ali picks up a vintage classic truck. Toby walks over and takes it from her.”
Told you it was tense! Is it just us, or has Toby never liked Ali? We wonder if this flashback scene takes place after “the Jenna thing” when Ali is convincing Toby to take the fall for the fire that she and the Liars started. It would certainly explain his animosity (though, Ali usually gives people more than one reason for being cross with her).
We believe this flashback scene will also include Toby’s mother, who is set to appear in the Season 4 premiere. As she is dead, this is probably her best chance. Judging by the scene transition in the script pic, this sneak peek seems to be the beginning of the scene, which means Marion Cavanaugh will pop in later. Hopefully, she won’t catch Toby and Ali doing anything untoward. In the Toby/Ali flashback scene in Season 3, we saw Ali visit Toby (and his do-rag) in juvie and say teasingly, “Bet you wish you’d kissed me when you had the chance.” Could she be referring to this moment?
What do you think is going on in this scene? When do you think it takes place? Let us know in the comments below!
Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, June 11, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.