Season 5 was a rocky one for Caroline and Tyler. They entered the season as a couple, though Tyler was off in Appalachia somewhere helping his fellow werewolves while Caroline began her stint as a college student. After some heartbreaking decisions, the two split up for good and attempted to salvage a friendship for the rest of the season.
We have to hand it to Candice and Michael — they really did give all-star performances, especially during the scene in which Caroline gave Tyler the ultimatum to either stay with her or head to New Orleans on his revenge mission against Klaus Mikaelson (Joseph Morgan). It was a poignant and emotionally raw scene, especially after all that these two had been through.
As for who these two are going up against, let’s check out the competition. In the category of Choice TV Male Scene Stealer, Candice is up against: Sarah Hyland (Modern Family), Eden Sher (The Middle), Naya Rivera (Glee), and Mayim Bialik (The Big Bang Theory). As for Michael, he’s going up against Darren Criss (Glee), Adam DeVine (Modern Family), Tyler Hoechlin (Teen Wolf), and Tahj Mowry (Baby Daddy) in the Choice TV Male Scene Stealer category.
Our Vampire Barbie and studly hybrid deserve some praise, and we hope they walk away winners on the big night!