Did Bachelor in Paradise’s Robby Hayes Already Cheat on Amanda Stanton?
Credit: Instagram    

Bachelor in Paradise

Did Bachelor in Paradise’s Robby Hayes Already Cheat on Amanda Stanton?


Though we knew Bachelor in Paradise Season 4 didn’t lead to any engagements, we were excited about one pairing: Amanda Stanton and Robby Hayes.

But just days after the couple went public with their romance, they’re already being plagued with cheating rumors.

Say it isn’t so!

This is not what fans had hoped for for Amanda, who just got over her messy on-again, off-again roller coaster with Season 3 fiancé Josh Murray.

And when photos emerged of her and Robby holding hands and dressing alike, they were excited by the prospect of this real life Ken and Barbie.

A post shared by E! News (@enews) on

That was, until potential scandal hit — and we’re not talking that Corinne Olympios-DeMario Jackson one.

Social media went into a tizzy over the weekend in the comments section of the below brunch pic posted by the Bachelorette 2016 hunk.

When a fan asked where the single mom was in the pic, a commenter by the name of “KelseyIswan” replied, “I’m assuming she wasn’t there because he was busy making out with the girl next to him at the ZBB concert last night.”

robby hayes instagram
Credit: Instagram    

Say what?! Why is the Florida native hooking up with another girl if he’s happily linked up with Amanda?

Spoiler king Reality Steve reached out to the commenter, who claimed that she was sitting a couple rows behind Robby and the blonde in the pic at the Zac Brown Band at Coors Field last Saturday.

“They were all over each other,” she tells him. “I’m honestly surprised no one else has come forward saying anything.”

The fan also says she snapped some pics of the makeout session, but has chosen to share those only with Amanda.

“It’s up to her what she does with it, but I was just trying to do the right thing,” she concludes.

As for the mystery woman, Steve believes her to be a gal named Lindsay Duke who is said to have previously hooked up with the BIP star.

Couldn't visit Orlando without making a little pit stop

A post shared by LINDSEY DUKE (@linds_duke) on

Still, in spite of the rumors, it looks like the 27-year-old beauty is sticking with her new beau for now.

A source tells Us Weekly this is all false and the two are still happily together.

“Amanda and Robby are still dating and have been dating since they got back from Paradise,” an insider tells the mag.

In regards to the alleged public makeout, the insider (likely close to Amanda or Robby) denies all claims.

“It wasn’t true,” the insider states.

Who do you believe? Sound off in the comments below.

Bachelor in Paradise premieres Monday, August 14 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.