American Idol fans have their final two contestants, but it might not be the Top 2 they were imagining.

In what can only be called an upset, Angie Miller was sent home during tonight’s elimination episode. That means Candice Glover and Kree Harrison will be duking it out for the Season 12 crown next week.

But why was Angie Miller eliminated?

If we were to guess, we’d chalk it up to another case of many fans taking for granted Angie would obviously make it. Another factor at play this season? Each of the Top 3 contestants was wildly talented in their own way, with no clear weak link. Unfortunately for Angie, she just happened to end up with the short end of the stick when it came to the public vote.

Even from the beginning, Angie Miller stood out as a fan favorite with seemingly the total package: She had stage presence, played the piano beautifully, and was even an accomplished songwriter. In fact, she took a major risk during Hollywood Week by performing an original composition. To this day, it’s still regarded as her best performances on the show.

Although she no longer gets to compete for the title of Season 12 champion, we’re sure Angie Miller has a bright musical future ahead of her.