Credit: Michael Becker/©2013 Fox Broadcasting Co.

We’ve reached the second week of American Idol and if last week's premiere was any indication, we're in for a phenomenal season! The show is already proving to be different from seasons past, as we’ve said goodbye to the judges’ squabbles and hello to Harry Connick, Jr! (Seriously, can that guy can’t get any more adorable? We don’t thinks so.)

Of course, the one thing that hasn’t changed are the numerous rounds of auditions. January 23’s episode finds the judges headed to Atlanta in hopes of tracking down the country’s next big thing.

It’s here where Keith UrbanJennifer Lopez, and Harry meet Neco Starr and Caleb Johnson. In the second mash-up of the evening (the first going to Kristen O’Connor and Emily Piriz) Neco and Caleb go head-to-head. Both do so well, we're once again torn on who will get that Golden Ticket and head to Hollywood. The judges seem equally conflicted and eventually decide, what the heck, send them both! 

Neco and Caleb are both on to Hollywood and we have another two strong competitors for this year's season! 

What do you think of Neco’s performance? How about Caleb’s? Did you have a favorite? Think both will make it to the Top 31? Read our spoilers here!


Elisabeth Kramer is an Assistant Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment and our resident Downton Abbey expert. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!