Credit: Michael Becker / FOX @2012 Fox Broadcasting Photo: Contestants Cheer for American Idol 2012 Hollywood Week

American Idol Season 11, The Final Judgment Part 2 ended with a major cliffhanger: The judges will be saving one male contestant, making the top 24 officially the top 25. The judges have already selected 12 girls and 12 guys, but in a shocking twist, they will add one more guy to the mix, choosing between one of four eliminated contestants: David “Mr. Steal Your Girl” Leathers, Jr., gentle giant Jermaine Jones, beefcake Johnny Keyser, and Heejun Han’s sworn enemy Richie Law.

Which of the four boys do you think should be given a second chance? Vote now — and tune in on Tuesday to watch the judges announce their decision on live television at 8/7c on FOX.