It finally happened. American Idol Season 12 is down to its Top 10. Voters got their chance to pick five guys and five girls, and the results were revealed on tonight’s episode. 

Check out who made it into the coveted spots, and let us know if you agree.

Paul Jolley
Paul Jolley was the first name called, which means that even if the judges couldn’t figure what kind of musician he wants to be, voters didn’t care. Are you digging his male Taylor Swift vibe?

Burnell Taylor
It seemed America agreed with Keith Urban, who gave Burnell Taylor a standing ovation the night before. Tonight, after his victory song,  Mariah Carey said, “I felt you.” Do you feel Burnell?

Curtis Finch, Jr.
“You’re one of the best singers in this whole thing,” Randy Jackson told Curtis Finch, Jr., adding that he was “So happy” to see the singer make it through. Do you agree?

Devin Velez
Devin Velez sings as effortlessly in Spanish as he does in English (and he loves his mama); did that convince you to vote for the crooner?

Lazaro Arbos
“He’s in it to win it,” said Randy Jackson of Lazaro Arbos last night. America wanted to give him that chance and voted him through. How far do you want to see him go?

Janelle Arthur
“Third time is the charm,” Ryan Seacrest tells Janelle Arthur. Evidently, voters felt Nicki’s marshmallow analogy and wanted to see “s’more” of the country singer. Do you like Janelle more than Seacrest’s recycled joke?

Candice Glover
Nicki had no words after Candice Glover’s performance a few nights ago, but viewers let their votes do the talking: They definitely wanted her to stick around. Are you stuck on Candice?

Angie Miller
It seems like America wants an Angie Miller record, just like Nicki Minaj does. Would you line up to buy an album from her — and are you glad you might one day get the chance?

Amber Holcomb
All four judges gave Amber Holcomb a standing ovation after a recent performance, and voters concurred with that sentiment. Does she make you want to stand up and cheer?

Kree Harrison
Nicki Minaj might want to make Kree Harrison her wife, but it seems America wants the country singer to be in the running for American Idol. Are you one of her fans?

Don’t see your favorite above? Here’s who got voted off:

Nick Boddington
Vincent Powell
Cortez Shaw
Elijah Liu
Charlie Askew
Zoanette Johnson
Aubrey Cleland
Tenna Torres
Adriana Latonio
Breanna Steer