Tonight’s American Idol 2013 auditions in Oklahoma City were short and sweet. We saw the good (Nate Tao’s rendition of “For Once In My Life”), the bad (Anastacia Freeman’s tone deaf take on “Unbreak My Heart”), and the crazy (Zoanette Johnson’s dizzying version of the National Anthem). We even got a surprise visit from former judge Steven Tyler, who showed up (unsurprisingly) in drag as a joke contestant.

But which audition was your favorite? Let us know by voting in the poll below!