Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: 'Idol' High School Prom Dates: Casey Abrams and Julie Zorilla

Okay American Idol fans, let’s try a little mental exercise.

Close your eyes and imagine Idol Season 10 contestant Julie Zorrilla… You know, the one whose shoes impressed Jennifer Lopez, and whose singing made all three judges crown her among the top Season 10 hopefuls? Got a mental picture? Good. Now imagine Casey Abrams… That’s right, he’s the soulful Seth-Rogan look-alike, who sang his way into the judges’ good graces.

Okay, now tell us, in your mental image of Julie and Casey, were the two on a prom date? NO?! Well, however hard to imagine, these two not only went to the same high school but also went to prom together. Crazy, we know!

Hmm, considering her J.Lo-approved fashion sense, Julie must have been dressed to the nines and looking smoking hot. But somehow we see Casey sporting evening wear of the blue tux with ruffled shirt variety!

Source: MJ’s Big Blog