Credit: Michael Becker/FOX; Ray Mickshaw/FOX ©2011 Fox Broadcasting Co. Photo: Jacob Lusk and Melanie Amaro Take on "Man in the Mirror" by Michael Jackson

During last week’s “Movie Night” theme on The X Factor, 18-year-old Melanie Amaro chose a rendition of “Man in the Mirror” by Michael Jackson (from his film This Is It). It may have seemed like a reach, but the girl seriously worked it.

But if you’re a loyal American Idol fan like us, you probably remember that Season 10 contestant Jacob Lusk also sang “Man in the Mirror” during the Top 9’s “Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall of Fame” show.

While it’s hard to ever top the King of Pop, which MJ performance did you like the best?

Credit: YouTube Photo: VIDEO: Melanie Amaro Sings "Man in the Mirror" by Michael Jackson on The X Factor, November 9, 2011