American Idol 2013 finalist Angie Miller has become the biggest question mark of the Top 4 when it comes to her success on the show. While she’s had the biggest online following of fans since her unforgettable performance of her original song, “You Set Me Free,” during Hollywood Week, she’s had a few more missteps than some of the others left in the competition.

Jimmy Iovine said she thinks Angie emotes too much, but we think her Achilles heel has been more about song choice. For instance, when she sang “Shop Around,” she seemed generally uncomfortable on stage. Last week, however, she showed us why we fell in love with her. She performed “I’ll Stand By You” in honor of her native Boston and she shined brightly, like she always does at the piano.

In fact, Keith Urban said she did so well, he looks forward to her going on the road. Angie passed on the piano to sing Beyonce’s “Halo,” however, and the judges still thought she was incredible. If she can have another moment like the one during Hollywood Week with her original song, she could easily win it all this season.

Watch Angie Miller's American Idol Top 4 performances and let us know if you think she's the girl to beat this season!

Angie Miller – “Who U R” by Jesse J

Credit: FOX Photo: Angie Miller Sings "Love Came Down" on American Idol 2013 Top 6

Angie Miller – “Cry Me A River” by Julie London



Angie Miller - Cry Me A River - American Idol... by IdolxMuzic
Credit: FOX Photo: Watch Angie Miller Sing Julie London's "Cry Me A River" in American Idol 2013 Top 4