In one of the most shocking eliminations in show history, Idol-darling Pia got the boot last week. The jaw-dropped look of Jennifer Lopez echoed our sentiments. We’re gonna miss that songstress’ voice, class... and fashion sense!

As usual, Pia nabbed one of our spots for best dressed of the week when she amped up her wardrobe — and song choice —  for her performance of “River Deep - Mountain High.” So, at least she made her exit in style? (We’re still sad she’s gone!) Find out who joins Pia at the sartorial top and who needs a bit of a makeover before this week’s Top 8.

Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: Pia Toscano Kicks It up on April 6, 2011

Best: Pia’s Bold Style Choices

Pia’s printed jumpsuit and bold necklace choice was so chic and cutting edge, it was made for the stage. She definitely went out with a bang in terms of style. So Pia!

Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: Haley Reinhart Gets Growly on April 6, 2011

Worst: Haley’s Ripped-up Mess

The plaid. The ripped-up hem. The rippled liquid-leggings... It didn’t fit well, and it wasn’t cohesive. It’s a style fail.

Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: James Durbin Gets Emotional on April 6, 2011

Best: James’ Sleek Suit

James packed up his normally edgy pieces and debuted a sleek, cool suit. We didn’t know he has this much sophistication in him, but the boy cleans up well!

Credit: Frank Micelotta/FOX Photo: Scotty McCreery Tries Something New on April 6, 2011

Worst: Scotty’s Jean-on-Jean

We’re not diggin’ Scotty’s jean-on-jean ensemble. Loved his performance, but his look needs an upgrade for next week.