Credit: FOX

Despite being called cross between Gwen Stefani and Carrie Underwood by Keith Urban during her Chicago audition, Stephanie Schimel was forced to sing for her life during Round 4 of Hollywood Week on American Idol 2013.

Her take on “Home,” Season 11 winner Phillip Phillips’s coronation song, showcased her delicately beautiful vocals. But the judges decided that Rachel Hale’s version of Haley Reinhart’s “Undone” was a stronger effort, advancing her to the Top 40 while cutting Stephanie from the competition.

But do you think Stephanie should have been sent home? Vote in our poll below and let us know!