Credit: People (via Yahoo) Photo: People Cover Jennifer Lopez

Former American Idol judge Jennifer Lopez showed up on the cover of People magazine on the same day Idol launched its new post-JLo season. Hmm. Coincidence?

But instead of being triumphant, the New York Post's
Page Six says JLo and her team aren't happy with the cover photo. 

"Her camp feels she looks old and haggard," a source told the site. Friends also compared her straight hair and bangs to quirky 70-year-old designer Betsey Johnson. Page Six heard that her team reached out to People to complain about the photo, but JLo's manager told the site they worked closely with People and were "very pleased" with the cover photo and overall results.

It's not like People ever features sexy cover photos like Glamour or Elle, so she had to know they'd be going with something a little different from her usual glam pose. Anyway, maybe this rumor was started by someone at Idol, wanting payback for stealing the spotlight. Nicki? Mariah? Or was it you, Keith? You're still the prettiest, man!

Source: Page Six