Her name might’ve been tossed into the ring for potential American Idol judges here and there, but Season 1 winner Kelly Clarkson says she had no interest in judging the beloved singing competition.

When asked by the Wall Street Journal if she’d ever judge Idol, Kelly responded, “No, I’d never do that.” Nope, no matter how many Grammy Awards she takes home.

She explained, “The one thing I did do was Duets on TV, and that was because I got to be a part of the process. I’m not really good at telling people how to do something. I’m better at showing them. So, yeah, that really wouldn’t be my forte.”

Despite what she says, we still think the outspoken singer would have been a great addition to the judging team.

You can watch the full interview below!

Credit: YouTube Photo: Kelly Clarkson Tells the Wall Street Journal Why She'd "Never" Judge American Idol