Remember that American Idol episode a few weeks ago, when Jennifer Lopez told Casey Abrams that he was sexy? Well, it seems that another member of the Idol family thinks so too!

Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: Haley Reinhart Takes the Stage in Season 10, Episode 14: The Top 12 Girls Perform

The rumors are flying that Casey and his fellow Idol finalist Haley Reinhart are an item.

One anonymous source told In Touch magazine, "Most of [Casey’s and Haley’s] downtime is spent together and they have a very touchy-feely relationship… They're always lying on each other when they're around the other contestants and everybody thinks they're hooking up." Do tell!

While Casey and Haley aren’t the most conventional couple in the world, we think they would be adorable together. With her big eyes and his curly hair, just think of their Fraggle-ish children! Okay, so maybe a Casey/Haley duet is a more reasonable request…

Source: In Touch