With the number of names being thrown around as potential judges for American Idol Season 12, we started wondering: Who do the fans want to see join Mariah Carey at the judging table?

So far, the people reportedly in negotiations for the gig are Nicki Minaj (who’s rumored to be a shoe-in, despite an allegedly unhappy Mariah), Adam Lambert (who claims to be just waiting on the green light), Kanye West, Nick Jonas (whose approval may or may not be up to M.C. herself), Pharrell WilliamsAlanis Morisette, and Brad Paisley.

Others like Lenny KravitzDiddy, Snoop DoggEnrique Iglesias, Keith UrbanCarrie UnderwoodAretha Franklin, and even Charlie Sheen have been mentioned as well.

Who would you pick to join the show as a judge? Weigh in with our poll!

Need your daily dose of American Idol? Like us on our Facebook page at facebook.com/AmericanIdolFansite, or follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/IdolWetpaint!