Credit: Michael Becker/FOX Photo: The Judges Approve in Season 10, Episode 9: Hollywood Round 2

It seems like only yesterday we were gearing up to watch the new judges traipse from town to town to find a new crop of Idol contestants. But alas, the Season 10 finale, and the newest American Idol, are upon us. May 25 marks the two-hour episode in which two hopefuls will go home and someone’s life will be changed forever. Our money’s on James. Or Scotty. Yeah, we can’t decide.