Hail to the Queen! The legendary rock band was on tap when the American Idol Top 6 performed on April 25, but then the contestants also got to choose any song they wanted. Oh, the possibilities. Phillip Phillips finally got to take on Dave Matthews (though he’s been channeling him all season), while Hollie Cavanagh reprised her Miley Cyrus audition song. Were these performances enough to keep them around another week? Tell us who you think won’t make it to the Top 5.