full size Elise Testone vs. Jersey Shore’s Snooki in Ema Savahl
Credit: Michael Becker/FOX; Jason Merritt/Getty Images

American Idol Top 13 contestant Elise Testone may not have wowed the judges with her performance on Wednesday, March 7, but she certainly looked the part of a star.

Her $1,275 Ema Savahl dress, which was provided by LendingLuxury.com, featured a tiger-inspired print in fiery shades of red. A metallic puffy paint design added even more intricacy and impact, which she matched with a gold flower bangle and sexy crimson nails.

Elise finished off the look with chunky platform heels and a feather in her hair — perfect additions to display her trademark bohemian vibe.

But the American Idol stage wasn’t the first place we’ve seen this Ema Savahl dress. Back in August 2011, Jersey Shore’s Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi stepped out for the MTV Video Music Awards in the exact same design.

Flaunting long streaked locks, glittering gold pumps, and jewelry with studs and spikes, Snook’s look was more of an in-your-face statement than hippie-glam.

Who’s take on the Ema Savahl dress do you like best?