Randy Jackson says he didn’t think it was her best performance but he loves that it means so much to her. Mariah Carey says she never heard the song before. Really? She thinks Janelle sang with truth and she felt her sing from her heart. Keith Urban says it is a beautiful song and he would have loved to see Janelle do the song just with her guitar and no frills or band backing her up.
Nicki Minaj says it was a sweet song and she liked it. She thinks this was a better performance than her first one tonight. However, she doesn’t think it was enough to get leg up over the other girls tonight.