Angie Miller's first song choice of the night for the American Idol Top 4 was Rihanna's "Diamonds." According to the judges, it wasn't one of her best performance.
Keith Urban commends Angie doing an original version of the song, but he thinks it was the wrong choice to strip down its unique structure. He thinks if she was going to change the tune so much, she should have taken it even further and changed the melody.
Nicki Minaj says she thinks the performance was “bland, it was lackluster” and she could do a lot better.
Randy Jackson says it was a great song, but he agrees with Keith that Angie's version of the song just didn’t go anywhere. He did like her leather shorts though. “I didn’t love it,” he says of her performance.
Mariah Carey feels like Angie tried to take the song to another place, but she was playing to the camera too much.