In her second song for the Top 5 American Idol performances show, Janell Arthur chose "Dumb Blond" by Dolly Parton.
Randy Jackson says he loves Dolly Parton and it was a fun song for her, although vocally it didn’t really show anything different for her. He thinks it was more of a performance than a vocal piece. Mariah Carey says she loves Dolly too and she thinks it was very “pow” and Janelle was connected to the song. Keith Urban isn’t sure he would place “Dumb Blond” high on the Dolly song list out of the incredible catalog she has. He doesn’t think it was the best song for her to shine on and “song choice is everything.” Nicki says she wants to be very careful about what she says because these Top 5 girls have superpowers. However, she does think Janelle is in jeopardy of going home tomorrow. But she still loves Janelle’s light and no matter what happens, she could still go very far in the real world.