Credit: Nigel Barker/Pottle Productions Inc ©2011 Pottle Productions Inc. Photo: Hannah's Other Photo on ANTM May 11, 2011

Let's start with the good stuff: When not crying sad model tears, Hannah was a little ball of positive energy. Guest judge Ivan Bart was spot on when he said she radiated something that Brittani and Molly lacked when they were lined up at panel. We also think it's true that her look makes a surprisingly easy transition between commercial and high fashion. Posing in a red Moroccan wedding gown on the beach, she looked like a bubbly blonde who also knows how to tell a killer Vogue story.

But here's the thing. More than once during Wednesday night's show, we wondered how Hannah got to the top three. Other than, you know, by not getting sent home. While Brittani and Molly's respective storylines on the show are a little more defined (perhaps a specific editing choice?), we kept asking ourselves basic questions about Hannah. Was she known for being super emotional? Did she take as many stunning photos as Tyra said? Is acting her thing? The answer is "yes" all around, but we had to think about it, and maybe that was the biggest problem.  

Unless you ask Andre. His biggest problem was probably Hannah's "absolutely ghastly" arched foot in her photo. Talk about an emotional response.