Credit: Walter Sassard/The CW ©2011 The CW Network, LLC. Photo: America's Next Top Model Cycle 17 Finale: The Judges in the Audience

When it rains, its pours. America's Next Top Model All-Stars had a generally lackluster season desperately lacking in drama, only to turn around in the finale and pack a wallop of a twist — but was it too much?

Angelea Preston's as-of-yet only vaguely explained disqualification was the kind of twist that should make reality TV fun, but it turned out to be mostly frustrating. The reason for her dismissal wasn't addressed on the show, and the entire issue was brushed away with a few words, leaving us too confused to even focus on the final judging. It didn't help that she'd had a rocking runway that left us thinking she might win, until the rug was pulled out from under us.

On top of that, the finale's runway show was  insane, and not in a good, we love Tyra's cray-cray way. All the dramatics — not to mention the bizarre editing — made it hard to tell if any of the finalists could actually, you know, walk down the runway like a regular model.

The cherry on top of it all was Lisa D’Amato's unexpected win, which we know disappointed Allison Harvard's legions of devoted fans.  All in all, All-Stars was not the triumphant success we'd hoped for.

What do you think: Has ANTM All-Stars turned you off of the show?

Want more from Wetpaint Entertainment? For all the latest on ANTM, "like" us on our Facebook page at facebook.com/ANTMFansite, or follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/ANTMWetpaint.