Credit: Nigel Barker/Pottle Productions Inc ©2011 Pottle Productions Inc. Photo: Angelea's Photo on America's Next Top Model Cycle 17, Episode 10

Yes, we’re all shocked by last night’s ANTM All Stars finale, especially by the way the judges and producers handled Angelea’s disqualification — such secrecy, surreptitious brevity, and shock value!

The conspiracy mill went into full combat mode last night, speculating on whether or not Angelea really did win in the first place. Is it possible that Angelea was the clear winner, and then did something erroneous (such as, leak the information) after the finale had been taped?

You tell us in our poll below! And keep sharing your thoughts on our ANTM All Stars Facebook page, where the rumors are flying as we type.

Want more from Wetpaint Entertainment? For all the latest on ANTM, "like" us on our Facebook page at facebook.com/ANTMFansite, or follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/ANTMWetpaint.