Credit: Ashley Benson Instagram Photo: Ashley Benson's Tangerine Lipstick

Pretty Little Liars star Ashley Benson has a distinctly different look than her on-screen counterpart Hanna Marin. While Hanna goes for the more trendy feminine styles, Ash is a bit edgier in her personal taste. Exhibit A: the tangerine lipstick she’s rocking in a recent Instagram shot. But can she pull it off?

“Super chic,” Ashley captioned the Instagram photo of herself with tangerine lipstick and some seriously baller sunglasses. But how do we really feel about the starlet’s bold lip color?

On the one hand, we think Ashley’s fair complexion is perfect for the brighter, more eccentric lip color. She also has a bit of the classic California sunglow to offset the tangerine. On the other hand, the tangerine might be too much for her pale complexion. Ash looks good in pretty much any color, but we can’t help but remember just how well the deep red tones of the lipstick she wore for the Kisses for the Troops campaign looked on Ash.

Ash seems to be experimenting a lot with lip color these days. Last week, she and co-star Shay Mitchell got all dolled up for a photo shoot. Ashley rocked a bubble gum pink shade of lipstick that seriously popped. Back in December, Ash went in the opposite direction, going Gothic with black lipstick. This woman knows how to mix it up!

Meanwhile, on PLL, Hanna has more to worry about than which color lipstick to don. Have you heard that love-of-her-life and all around good guy Caleb will be back as a series regular in Season 5?

Do you think Ashley looks good in the tangerine lip color? Which lip look of hers is your absolute favorite? Sound off in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on June 10, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

Kayti Burt is a contributing writer for Wetpaint Entertainment with a penchant for all things pop culture. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!