Credit: ABC/Bob D'Amic

Your favorite Bachelor Nation-ers are just normal people that find love through Tinder… sort of. The clever folks over at E! News came up with a fun little game for some of the cast of ABC’s new Bachelor/ette spin-off, Bachelor in Paradise — they got them to swipe left or right (for newbies, left is “no thanks” and right is “yes, please!) for past Bachelors and Bachelorettes! Yep, it’s as juicy as it sounds.


Those participating were AshLee FrazierGraham BunnLacy FaddoulMarcus GroddMichelle Money and Robert Graham, and they did not hold back! For those still on good terms with their original lead, they were much kinder and swiped right (i.e. Robert and Desiree Hartsock or Graham and DeAnna Pappas). The awkward ones? When Lacy was faced with Juan Pablo Galavis (who eliminated her on night one during his Bachelor season), and AshLee had to swipe for this man Sean Lowe, who broke her heart during Fantasy Suites. Woof.

Other notable choices? Marcus seems to really only be into brunettes (guess that was a given), Michelle totally friend-zoned Chris Harrison, and Lacy’s already forgotten about Bachelor 16’sBen Flajnik. Looks like Courtney Robertson has an ally in Ms. Faddoul!

Read on for all the fantasy Bachelor and Bachelorette dating!

Robert Graham (Desiree Hartsock's season)

Andi Dorfman: Left

Desiree Hartsock: Right

Emily Maynard: Right

Ali Fedotowsky: I don't know.

DeAnna Pappas: Graham's season? Graham's my boy and they didn't work out, so I'll say left!

Trista Sutter: I know of her, but I don't know anything about her, so I'll say right.

Graham Bunn (DeAnna Pappas's season and Bachelor Pad)

Andi: Right

Desiree: Right

Emily: Right

Ali: Right

DeAnna: Triple right.

Trista: Double right.

Marcus Grodd (Andi Dorfman's season)

Andi: Right

Desiree: Right

Emily: Left

Ali: Left

DeAnna: Right

Trista: Right

AshLee Frazier (Sean Lowe's season)

Juan Pablo Galavis: Left

Sean Lowe: Left

Ben Flajnik: Left

Jason Mesnick: Right

Brad Womack: Right

Chris Harrison: Right, right?!

Michelle Money (Brad Womack's season and Bachelor Pad)

Juan Pablo: Left

Sean: Left, he's married!

Ben: Left

Jason: Left

Brad: Left

Jake: Liggity, liggity left!

Chris: Neutral! I love Chris Harrison. He's one of my dear friends, so I would just put him right in the middle in the friend zone!

Lacey Faddoul (Juan Pablo's season)

Juan Pablo: Left

Sean: Right

Ben: I don't know who he is…right.

Jason: Right

Jake: Right

Brad: Right

Chris: Right

Are you surprised by any of these choices? Do you agree or disagree? Sound off below!

Source: E! News