Remember when, during last night’s Episode 5 of Bachelor in Paradise, newbie Christy Hansen shared that she’d never had a threesome during a game of “I Never”? Well, Christy is still insisting that she still falls in that “never” category — despite what appeared to have happened between the blonde, Jesse Kovacs, and Lucy Aragon.


Credit: ABC/Francisco Roman

As the episode was airing, the Bachelor 18 alum took to Twitter to deny any sort of menage a trois situation. “NEVER HAVE I EVER HAD A THREESOME. EVER,” Christy tweeted definitively.

So what gives? Was this a clever case of editing on those ABC producers’ parts (par for the course at this point), or is the 25-year-old trying to do a little damage control after her risque act was shown on national television?

Our guts are going with… a little bit of both. While we hear that there was no actual sex going down in that Tulum room, something definitely happened. Perhaps those evil geniuses behind the scenes wanted us to believe it was a full blown menage, but it may have been something less extreme. Not sure what Christy defines as a threesome, but guess this didn’t fall into the category.

Whatever the case may be, next week’s Episode 6 will likely hash this stuff out further — even though “free spirit” Lucy has jetted off-island. Is the drama between Christy and Jesse something new, or just that fateful night coming back to bite them in the bootie? We’ll have to tune in to find out!

What do you think really happened? Sound off in the comments below.