It’s been more than 10 years since ‘N Sync took a “temporary hiatus” (aka the worst day of our lives), and today the boys — Justin Timberlake, JC Chasez, Lance Bass, Joey Fatone, Chris Kirkpatrick —  have grown into handsome men, sans the cornrows and braids. Only of them is even a father! Gasp.

Joey, 37, is the proud papa of two girls, 13-year-old Briahna Joely and 4-year-old Kloey Alexandra, and he seems to be the only one in the Dad Club… for now. In case you need a refresher, Chris and Justin are both married (to Karly Skladany and Jessica Biel respectively), Lance is engaged to Michael Turchin, and JC is the last single man standing.

“Smart guy,” Joey jokes to Wetpaint Entertainment during the 2014 FIFA World Cup McDonald’s Launch Party in New York City on June 5. “Just teasing!”

But what about the rest of the boy banders? Following Justin’s “new baby” toast during a concert in April, which left fans thinking he and Jess were expecting, we can’t help but wonder if the couple are ready to make their family a party of three!

“I think probably Chris would be the next one,”Joey says. “I wouldn’t be surprised if he and Karly had a kid, but then again, you never know with Justin and Jess. You never know what’s going to happen.”

Joey went on to say, “Obviously with their careers, it’s very tough to do that stuff, unless Jess says, ‘Hey, let’s do this,’ but I don’t know if there’s any plans soon, or if they’re trying.

“I’m sure newlyweds are trying a lot as far as Chris is concerned,” Joey adds with a laugh. “If anything, I would probably say Chris.” And there you have it!

We’ll be keeping an eye on these guys, because you never know, maybe a new baby will bring about another reunion of sorts. Here’s to wishful thinking!

Who do you think will be having a baby next? Tell us your thoughts in the comments below!