Once Upon a Time

Which Reality Star Did Colin O’Donoghue and Michael Raymond-James “Geek Out” Over? (PHOTO)

We admit that it’s easy to fangirl over Once Upon a Time hotties Colin O’Donoghue (Captain Hook) and Michael Raymond-James (Nealfire), though we never expected them to fanboy over someone — especially a reality TV star!

At San Diego Comic-Con last weekend, the guys snapped a pic with a star whom they both adore, and we can’t get over how cute it is. Click on to see who made them “geek out”!